Simply by the first conversation. It depends on what we're doing. Nightfalls, I don't really care as long as you're 34. VoG? I don't feel like spending 4 hours trying to carry so I'll see who mows what to do and leave if I know it'll take more than an hour. CE? Dont care, just need a warlock and a sword bearer. POE? dont care. Skolas? Obviously need to assess whether it'll take too long with what they know and have. THIS should be the way "judging" should go. I prefer to use the term assess.