Hey Bungie,
I actually felt like my gear made a significant difference. There would be times where I knew I didn't deserve to live through a particular engagement, but did, thanks to my maxed-out gear and light level. Tactics and skill definitely still worked to my team's advantage, allowing my 29 teammates to be just as pro as I remember them, even when pitted against 30s. Heavy Ammo was a very important match balancer, because GJALLARHORN KNOWS NO LEVEL or something.
Since most of the people who I played against this week were level 28, 29, or 30, it might make more sense to have a curved competitive zone, where level 30s are competitive with 29s, 29s with 30s and 28s, 28s with 29s, 27s, and 26s, letting the competition gap narrow as you reach the top and widen as you first begin.
I also didn't see much of an issue with using my Thunderlord with an attack rating of 267 making that much of a difference under my Swarm at 300. And I did scoff at level 29s who used [i]blue[/i] guns with a maximum rating of 242 edging out my 300 gear when in a reasonably straight gunfight.
It felt like armor mattered more than weaponry.
Oh, I know it's not in the scope of Iron Banner development, but it definitely needs a mention: connection quality. When I was in a fireteam with some of my buddies from across the US, I had between 1-4 people each game with garbage-tier connections. I would rather have waited for a better quality match when in a fireteam than to have yelled so many obscenities at my screen. Matchmaking made gameplay with friends who lived a few states away less desirable than playing alone, communicating with whoever else opted into team chat.
Also, huge shout-out to team chat. Impeccable timing with the breakdown of XBL Party Chat and what-all.
Overall, great job. Seriously, I've had a good time with the event and I'm enjoying my classy Iron Banner Mittens and Socks.
-Federal
-
-
It's pretty clear that light level and perks matter more than the "Attack" level on guns. The way I understand it, the Attack on a weapon is simply a multiplier which determines damage falloff against enemies which are higher level than you. So it makes some degree of sense that blue weapons would still be fully viable in the hands of a high level enemy. However, there does seem to be an actual damage boost associated with maxing a legendary or exotic weapon. My Fixer went from 80 dmg on headshots to 89 dmg, when I fully maxed it. It's not enough for a 2 shot kill, but it does help when engaging enemies with your teammates. There's a slight benefit, but it's not overpowered.
-
I have maxed out guns that don't kill at point blank range. I'm glad you're enjoying this bullshit though