This is pretty much everything that people has been saying since the game released (hell, the beta even). The reviewer even spent about 40 hours playing the game, so there's no excuse you can bring up of him "rushing through" it.
It is the very personification (er-gameification) of "Jack of all trades, master of none." Destiny pulls from so many different things without understanding what makes them good, or really [i]doing[/i] anything with them. A shame, really.
-
Gamespot has never givin good reviews, they are always caught up in hypes and expectations. A lot of their reviews are biased based on what counsel or company they are into at the time. Look at things like their titianfall review, what a joke.