halo reach with all it's gametypes, forged maps, no bloom gaemtype download, awesome remakes like guardian or killhouse from cod 4. That said, all i need in reach is a battle rifle skin for the dmr and halo 3 skin for my armor (i hate halo reach's desgin) in any case, halo always wins when compared to cod even halo 4. though cod 4 is be better in campaign gameplay than halo 4 (equal in story)