Hey, hey guys, hey, look, it says [b]opinion[/b] in the title. Hey, hey guys, guess what? That means it's, like, my opinion. How I feel about the consoles. With that in mind...
So, today is PS4 launch day in Europe, and I've now got my hands on both an Xbox One and a PS4, and at least one game for each of them (sadly PSN is down, or was down, when I tried to sign into my account and get the F2P games, but that's not the point). Don't believe me? Well that's your loss and frankly I don't care (or there's a picture embedded above just for you). So, let's begin.
[u]CONTROLLER:[/u]
I knew, going into the purchases, that the Xbox One controller would be better than the Xbox 360 controller (having used it prior to launch), and that the DualShock 4 controller would be better than the DualShock 3. While the Xbox One controller is certainly an improvement on the 360 controller, it's still not "perfect", with triggers I personally find a little too sensitive on Forza 5. The impulse triggers are really nice though. As far as I could tell, the battery life was good as well. I used the AAs from the box and am now on a play and charge kit.
The DS4 is, however, easily the biggest improvement on its predecessor. The DS3 was a [i]horrible[/i] controller. I hated it and everything it stood for. Bastard thing. But the new DS4 is incredibly good compared to its older brother. Nicer triggers (or should I say, actual triggers), comfortable sticks, and an all-round great feel. Very impressed, Sony. But is it better than the One controller?
In my opinion (remember that part, yo), no. The Xbox One controller wins. But damn the DS4 is good.
[u]Noise:[/u]
What? Sorry, I can't hear you over the sound of how awesome these consoles are. Wait, maybe that's actually the PS4's cooling fans I can hear... Yep. Sadly, the PS4 makes a lot more noise than the Xbox One when in use, especially when running Killzone Shadowfall. Even now, it's paused in-game and making a hell of a lot of noise. I can hear it over the Xbox One, which is running Forza 5, also paused in-game.
In contrast, the Xbox One runs nearly silent, no matter what you're asking it to do. I'd even say the power brick makes more noise under my desk than the console itself, but with the acoustics caused by the wooden floor and several wooden "walls" around it, that could be exaggerated beyond its actual sound level. Still, good mark for the Xbox there.
[u]Graphics:[/u]
Well, they're still not PCs. I should know; my rig laughs at the 1080p output of these consoles. Scoffing as it smothers itself with baby oil and bathes in the tears of console peasants. Wait, sorry, got a bit off topic there.
The Xbox One and PS4 both display games beautifully, with each console's first-party exclusives looking mighty fine indeed. And that says a lot, considering we're at the very beginning of the life span of these consoles. Hell, look at a launch title for the PS3 and Xbox 360, compared to say, Halo 4 (shut up it's gorgeous and you have no idea what you're talking about) or GTA V. With those differences, I'm super stoked to see what's to come in the next few years.
Running their own exclusives on a 1440p monitor, the games across both consoles look great. It's a less-than-ideal test, because the monitor resolution is greater than the consoles output while gaming, but I make do. Both look great. No real winner here. Too early to tell.
[u]UI and navigation:[/u]
Well, this is an easy one. The PS4's home screen is much improved over the PS3, and I really like how simple it is to get where you want to go. There are still issues, don't get me wrong. Sub menu after sub menu gets a bit tedious and confusing as you dive deeper, but it's still better than the PS3. Not to mention that you can switch to a movement-based typing control when you're entering text. Pointing the controller (without the camera, by the way) allows you to pick letters to type with effortlessly, with precision. Much faster than using the sticks to select letters, but still not keyboard fast.
The Xbox One, on the other hand? Well, the Xbox On command doesn't always work. Mark down against the Xbox there. The dashboard/home is great, although very similar to Windows 8. Which I'm not a fan of (sure is opinions in here). But what wins it all for me is the Kinect integration. Xbox, go to Forza Motorsport 5. BAM, I'm loading Forza. Xbox, snap Skype. BAM! Skype is opened beside Forza. "Switch", I say, as the Xbox is still listening to my commands. I'm back in control of Forza while Skype loads next to it. It finishes loading and I get a call. Xbox, answer that. Done. Damn, I forgot he's on FIFA 14 (this only works if you have the digital copy of games). Xbox, go to FIFA 14. Almost instantly, I'm no longer on Forza, and I'm loading up FIFA 14. Faster than the Xbox 360 can eject a disc. Faster than I can get to the games on my Steam library.
Serious win for the Xbox in this section. What's next? Hmm, well, this is only really a first impression. I've had the Xbox One since launch, and today is just my first day with the PS4. I'm sure I'll find more things I like and dislike as time goes on, but for now, here's the verdict:
I prefer the Xbox One.
WOAH SHIT, easy there tiger, remember - this is my opinion.
So, anyone else got either or both consoles? What do you think about them? Let's hear it.
[quote]Update for anyone interested: I've been using the PS4 for the last few hours and I really, I mean REALLY, like the controller. Starting to warm to it rather heavily. Location of the options and share buttons are annoying though; I keep going to press them and end up clicking the touch pad. Something I'll get used to eventually I guess.[/quote]
-
Ok, I like the Xbox One because of the games, I don't care about Graphics or Specs, I just like it, and if you disagree about it, you are just a Fanboy who has no life but playing Video games, the games appeal to me on the Xbox, that's why I bought it, not because of 1080p 60FPS games, just get a 60 inch TV that does 1080p 240hz like mines. Second, my friends are buying this, like again, I don't fuc**ng care about specs or capabilities, all I care about is playing with the people who play with you everyday and enjoy the time with you, and if your lone, it will be like, an island, yah you can always make new friends, but they won't be like the friends you already have
-
I approve of this thread, I can tell that you have taken the time to set both consoles up correctly and use them. Especially how you actually see the Kinect for what it really is, a bloody UI controller, and a fine one at that
-
The only things that made me choose PS4 was lack of Shitty kinect, and exclusives. Only xbox exclusives I like are the halo games.
-
This thread is so old, I think I see a bit of mold.
-
Interesting stuff :-)
-
I agree with this completely. I have played a PS4 a lot and own and Xbox One but love the Xb1 controller more and the layout.
-
on top of making a great review you managed to get goheels to rage as well. excellent work.
-
Stupid -blam!-ing -blam!-. You -blam!-ing bitch you're supposed to blindly follow one -blam!-ing company and worship them unconditionally. You idiot you're not allowed to form -blam!-ing opinions here.
-
Edited by Azraels Sorrow: 1/1/2014 5:09:48 PMI do like the one a lot. In fact the only voice command that give me trouble is xbox on. Only works half the time and I don't know why cause once on the commands work great ( especially once I got a tv mount and put it above my tv). Graphics are great. I am blown away by Ryse's graphic and it is fun. With my kids running around it is nice to easily go to TV and when they leave I can go right to were I was in the game. Now I wait for Titanfall. I do have one problem. Were is the recent players list. I had to exit a game and wanted to invite the guy I had met back but I couldn't look him up on recently played list because I can't find it
-
Could you be anymore biased? My PS4 runs almost dead silent. I can't hear it when I'm playing a game. Games factually have better graphics on PS4. If you can't see the difference get glasses. The hardware is much more powerful. PS4 has a better UI if you don't want to spend an extra $100 to talk to your TV. The UI on PS4 was built for controller use and most people prefer that.
-
That is a lot of extremely wrong biased information
-
[quote]I should know; my rig laughs at the 1080p output of these consoles. Scoffing as it smothers itself with baby oil and bathes in the tears of console peasants. Wait, sorry, got a bit off topic there.[/quote] I got a good laugh out of that.
-
It wouldn't have mattered to me whether you came out liking the PS4 or the Xbox One better -- either way, this review is well-written, unbiased, and interesting. Better than most of the "PS4 vs Xbox One reviews" that I've read on the video game news websites. Great job and thanks for posting!
-
I own both too and I definitely prefer the Xbox.
-
Owned both. Xb1 for sure
-
[quote]no real winner on graphics[/quote] Yep, nothing to see here. I also own both consoles and have put them both SIDE BY SIDE. If you can't tell the difference you might be retarded. Regarding the rest of the post, it's pretty much the most biased shit I've ever read.
-
Edited by Failure4Life: 5/16/2014 12:23:45 PMI haven't had any noise issues with my PS4, it is quieter than a homosexual's fart.
-
Nicely done, thank you for no fanboy blurts.
-
Edited by ZERO XVII 17: 5/16/2014 4:56:19 PMI only own a PS4, but based on my experience it does have some software issues currently, but they are really random and rarely happen. I still like the PS4 exclusives more than the XOne. Currently both systems are now the same in price and features. I would get an XOne, but I can't willingly give money to Microsoft after the -blam- they tried to pull when the console first launched and for introducing a paid subscription service for online games that is becoming standard.
-
I have an Xbox One an i am in love for sure!
-
"i have one game, but I know these consoles in and out even though I haven't owned the PS4 for more than 24 hours" I don't care, why post this when you know you're going to start a flamewar. "but muh opinions" no one gives a -blam!- about your opinions but people who hold the same ones.
-
Somethings wrong with ur ps4 mine is silent
-
Good post man. Appreciate it.
-
Edited by Plasma Prestige: 1/6/2014 7:24:28 PMThe graphics on the PS4 are better, as of now. There really is no question about that. Other than that, it seems like a fair comparison. EDIT: Actually, I have no idea what you're talking about with Noise. I can't hear my PS4, disc or no disc, when playing 64 player BF4 on low volume.
-
[quote]Nor does powering on the console start up the controller, unlike the Xbox 360[/quote] The 360 doesn't turn on your controller...but yeah, the "Xbox On" command never works for me so I just turn on the controller to turn on everything, just like I did with the 360.
-
WHAT? YOU LIKE THE XBONE? YOU WILL FALL, LIKE THE OTHERS!!! But nice review of sorts, dude. I love the Xbox One for the most part, it's just that it needs a few software updates to bring back voice messages, storage management, and easier party chat. The 360 did party chat perfectly, so Microsoft should bring it back as it was.