{{
`${userDetail.user.displayName}${userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode ? `#${standardizeBungieGlobalCode(userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode)}` : ""}`}}
{{getUserClans()}}
originally posted in:Secular Sevens
9/16/2013 11:52:18 PM
1
[quote]My dad's cancer[/quote]That he got cancer, or that he survived cancer?
Either way, there's tons of science and medicine behind it, and directly works against the existence of a benevolent god.
English
-
Edited by Butters: 9/16/2013 11:58:33 PMHe survived it and it's gone, and I don't see how the science and medicine involved disprove God. He isn't a magic doctor who selectively heals random people, he gave us free will and difficulties for a reason. It's all personal perspective on scenarios, I can imagine I have put more thought into my life and beliefs in one year than you have in your entire life. And again I ask, what experiences compel you to insist that God isn't real.
-
So he didn't see a doctor or have chemo?
-
He did go through all of that. However, you wouldn't know what it was like dealing with all that and how the experience could possibly be more positive on my faith.
-
None of that supports the existence of god. It supports effective study and practice of medicine.
-
I never said his healing was from God, it was clearly from science and medicine. I said the experience and all that happened strengthened my faith.
-
You don't think it's odd that a benevolent, all-powerful, all-loving being with the power to create and destroy whatever he wants let your dad get cancer?
-
Why would he pick and choose who gets to benefit or gets a better treatment. We face difficulties to help us grow and become better individuals, with divine intervention then free will is not true and our lives aren't based on how we guide them and live them. I wrote a two page single spaced paper on this whole thing already for my Meditation class, I'd rather not go into it again.
-
Edited by Mr Shojo Rising: 9/17/2013 12:36:20 AMI'm not talking about the treatment, I'm talking about why he let your dad get cancer to begin with. Why does cancer even exist in the world? Assuming the premises that god is perfect, all-powerful, and benevolent are true, creating/letting cancer to exist in the world goes against each one of those claims. If god purposefully created cancer, he is not benevolent. If god does not have the ability to remove cancer, he is not all-powerful. If god did not purposefully create cancer, he is neither all-powerful nor perfect.
-
>Creates the universe and our planet >Allows us to develop into our free-willed species >Allows the world to develop around us >Should just jump in and remove cancer despite it being a part of life What's the point of removing cancer, that would mean for one intervening with our lives, two would mean he might as well remove anything that could harm us, and three would mean that we might as well shouldn't have free will since we can't handle life situations. If my dad had died then I still would have faith in God, looking at negatives only negatively causes you no personal gain. The times of your life where you experience the biggest personal growth is in uncomfortable, stressful, or hard times. God created free will and decision making because he is benevolent. He allows us to live our lives on our own and to grow because he is benevolent. He allows us opportunities to grow because he is benevolent. Why would he remove cancer and show his power when that defeats the purpose of a life of struggles and growing? Half of the shit you're spewing seems to be based on creationism.
