For me, it was Halo 4.
I thought it was going to bring back the classic Halo that I liked. Honestly, I wanted it to be a Halo 3.5. That hope was quickly crushed by the return of armor abilities and other crap.
-
4, I was expecting a game that brings Halo above CoD, except it came out as a game that adopted a lot of things from CoD and other generic FPSs.