JavaScript is required to use Bungie.net

OffTopic

Surf a Flood of random discussion.
Edited by ash: 2/4/2013 5:13:45 PM
42

Why do we portray war positively and defend its violence?

One of my friends sent me the above vid, and I thought about his points. I always see that ads try to say that soldiers fight for our freedom everyday, like if they stopped shooting for a day, we'd be invaded. Like if they would stop launching airstrikes, we wouldn't be able to live happily. Like if we stopped sending young men and women to their deaths, we'd be enslaved by terrorists. They, IMO, don't fight for our freedom right now. This fight is a useless one. It is one the Soviets tried and failed, and is one we will also fail to do. We should stop thinking that we're freeing people or saving them by putting their country into more of a shit hole than what they started out as. One of my distant cousins joined the military, he seemed like he was brainwashed by some recruiter, saying his college will be payed for, he'll see new places, have an adventure, make life long friends. He used to be funny and out going. But when he came back and we visited him, he wasn't the same. Him and a bunch of his buddies from high school went with him, some of them are dead and most of them were severly maimed. Lucky for him onlly was shot 5 times and had two toes blown clean off. I KNOW he's suffering from PTSD, but he has to much pride in him to admit to it. He finished his college since then, but I don't see much of him anymore. His service is still highly respected by me, despite the feelings I have towards war violence, but I think we need to fight wars the REALLY matter. The fights we fight now don't. Stopping Hitler from killing anymore millions of people was "the fight for freedom". But we don't have wars like this anymore. We should stop glorifying war unless the cause is worth the death and suffering.

Posting in language:

 

Play nice. Take a minute to review our Code of Conduct before submitting your post. Cancel Edit Create Fireteam Post

View Entire Topic
  • What I don't get is the people saying "We're fighting for the rights of others." Yes, we are, but is it a worthwhile fight? We're fighting to [i]change an entire culture[/i]. No amount of bullets, assassinations, and bombings is going to do that. It's just not. If people hate something, or don't believe in something, they're not going to be changed by the US military coming in and saying "Stop that! You are now a democratic country that believes in equal rights for all, and free speech, and ideological freedom, despite the fact that you haven't been that way for decades, if not longer!" It just won't work, and the idea that it will is foolish. I'm not saying "leave everyone alone and they'll work out their own problems eventually," but at the same time, I kind of am. You have to wait for people to want change before you can fight to defend it. Look at the American south. Even after the Civil War (which I know, wasn't originally about ending slavery), the south only grudgingly gave up its slaves, and many people there often made conditions for the newly freed blacks so poor that they essentially still were slaves. Moving forward, the civil rights movement wasn't born in the US military; it was born in the oppressed, and they sought out their own means of freedom. The time for the US military came when it was time to enforce these newly established rights for blacks, when the idea was already set and defended by the people living there. Not to mention the fact that giving blacks/minorities equal rights took the United States decades. One could argue that equal rights is still not truly achieved even today. Why, then, do we look towards other countries with problems of discrimination and inequality and say "Our military needs to protect the rights of others?" like that's a job that's easily attainable within a decent time-span? It's wishful thinking, but more dangerous, because it's a factor of the support for these long, dragging, unbelievably expensive wars.

    Posting in language:

     

    Play nice. Take a minute to review our Code of Conduct before submitting your post. Cancel Edit Create Fireteam Post

    7 Replies
    You are not allowed to view this content.
    ;
    preload icon
    preload icon
    preload icon