{{
`${userDetail.user.displayName}${userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode ? `#${standardizeBungieGlobalCode(userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode)}` : ""}`}}
{{getUserClans()}}
6/28/2024 2:55:09 AM
4
i mean, a writer at bungie confirmed they were always intended to be read as lovers, but sure keep talking.
English
-
Edited by HollowKage: 6/29/2024 5:58:22 PMWelp…
-
Not what they said here https://youtu.be/-bjl7RiAR9c
-
Edited by xbroggiex: 6/28/2024 12:26:42 PMContext is that he(Robert Brookes) always believed they were gay before he even became a writer at Bungie and as soon as he obtained any form of power over the story he hamfisted the retcon in. It shows bad writing that he ignored all previous lore to rewrite characters to fit his own fan-fiction made cannon, this was never represented in any release before he started writing for Destiny. Reading anything pre-brookes shows that they were BFFs or brothers in arms. Even when they fight in to CoO comic Saint literally calls Osiris "brother".
-
Honestly I started in Shadowkeep so I was not aware of previous lore that they weren't a couple, though Saint-14 going into the Infinite Forest to find Osiris and then Osiris bending time to try and save Saint-14 does make equal sense for love and/or camaraderie. But someone mentioned the Devil's Ruin "mission" where we have both Saint-14 and Osiris in call together for the first time and watching it now, their tone is strikingly different than it is currently. It is much closer to how close friends would joke with each other; Saint-14 telling to Osiris to leave the call, -blam!- "make me" and his reply is "you would not survive that, (but) you make me laugh so you can stay." Not quite the tone for lovers, at least how I understand it. Nothing wrong with them being lovers however, again it does make some semblance of sense but it does indeed appear to be a retcon to fit a narrative and that in itself feels wrong. Still, not a fan of love stories to begin with and it seems like we are going to end up with a wedding at the end of this Episode, just based on how the writing is going.
-
[quote]Context is that he(Robert Brookes) always believed they were gay before he even became a writer at Bungie and as soon as he obtained any form of power over the story he hamfisted the retcon in. It shows bad writing that he ignored all previous lore to rewrite characters to fit his own fan-fiction made cannon, this was never represented in any release before he started writing for Destiny. Reading anything pre-brookes shows that they were BFFs or brothers in arms. Even when they fight in to CoO comic Saint literally calls Osiris "brother".[/quote] This
-
Who said this and when?
-
I apologise for coming across as hostile earlier. I had been through a fair few posts before yours and assumed that you were also being hostile. [url=https://x.com/sphynxian/status/1332749010478665728?s=46]Relevant thread.[/url]
-
[quote]I apologise for coming across as hostile earlier. I had been through a fair few posts before yours and assumed that you were also being hostile. [url=https://x.com/sphynxian/status/1332749010478665728?s=46]Relevant thread.[/url][/quote] I'll give you this... you're courteous and much more polite than most people on these forums.
-
No problem dude. Have a good day
