They keep saying something about "abusing dark magic", and "dating monsters is wrong", and "how I should be crystallized for my crimes against nature". We can't keep them because my family already has too many otherworldly magical beings. We already tried feeding them, and giving them some water, but they smacked it out of my hands and accused me of trying to poison them.
What else should I do? Nobody has come looking for them yet.
-
When I'm really really not sure, we try to just send it to the pocket dimension so we can deal with it if and/or when we figure it out. Eventually this strategy might become an issue but if it ain't broke....