TL;DR: Some positives but I feel like it's lost a bit of its identity / positive gameplay aspects via unnecessarily changing things that separated Destiny from the herd.
I know it's a beta and plenty of things will be changing but I just wanted to weigh-in and give my initial impressions on the beta experience so far on the off chance that it catches somebody's eye.
For reference on my perspective, while I could hold my own in most D1 PVP matches, I was roughly 80% PVE / 18% PVP / 2% Dancing in the tower. With that said, I was really excited by the story telling aspects and the visuals; seeing the NPCs actually move and and physically interact with the world / player was a giant stride in the right direction. You've also presumably retained the gist of the social PVE experience that had set Destiny apart in that regard.
I do have some critiques though - and I'm not trying to offend anybody or anything - just airing my opinions. I feel like some of the gameplay was lost with the new weapon scheme. In D1, everything was fast-paced and, when I was playing well, it felt action scene-esque as I'd transition between my primary, to secondary, run-slide-melee, to heavy, to a super to mop up. A lot of that has been lost a bit with the new weapon scheme. Shotguns/snipers were a fun little part of the dance. Reading the threads, the general consensus seems to be that the move was made for PVP - which I don't know about... I honestly have always played shooters that had snipers hat could one-hit you from far away and shotguns that could from up close and I've never given it a second thought... its part of the rock-paper-scissors dynamic of shooting games where different builds work better in different situations... so for me, it's really weird (and bland) to have a PVP that's devoid of either because everybody is grabbing rocket launchers or fusion rifles (in my experience) and, in countdown, there's no point in wasting heavy on a sniper when usually 2 or 3 are dead by the time a sniper spawns.
Perhaps partially due to that, I was honestly surprised by how slow everything felt in PVE - even the movement. Maybe the levels just have more wide-open spaces so the feeling is relative to the environment though, to be fair. Also, I haven't read anything about this, so it's probably just me, but I had to max out even my controller sensitivity setting to 10... and it still feels a little sluggish.
PVP was a total bust for me. The articles all talk about "focusing on teamwork"... which sounds great, but I think reducing numbers really only increases the premium on individual skill. If both teams are doing what they're supposed to, then it's just a quick succession of one-on-one fights with damaged victors battling it out until it's done. And besides the team damage modifier, it's easier to compensate for a weak (or AFK) member of a team while they learn the ropes - these maps and and lobbies are so small that a weak team member will likely get roughed up quite a bit. Plus, the 4-on-4 means anybody AFK / dropping out of your team (which, in my experience, has been happening more often than not for one team or the other) makes winning a pretty much impossible task if the other team stays even remotely together. I know some have suggested allowing join-ins, but that team still is probably getting tossed for two rounds or a minute or so while that player would fly-in. What baffles me though is that Destiny 1 had trials which was pretty much this exact same for the same purpose. Folks that were good and / or enjoyed it went there - but there's something to be said for the countless that didn't because it wasn't their cup of tea. Also, that's going to be a harsh welcoming party for any players new to Destiny to try and get invested in. Bleh, anyway... just baffling.
Honestly, the saddest part for me was that I played a few rounds and just was kind of done with it. It wasn't fun or gripping like I expected. This is coming from somebody that's done about 200 too many Omnigul runs throughout the days. I don't know, I was really excited about the game but it doesn't feel like Destiny anymore and I don't think I'll be doing the pre-order anymore unless some more of the secrecy starts to be unveiled soon. Good luck though and I'll keep my eyes on it to see if it becomes more of a game that fills that niche that Destiny 1 did. :)
(To those that loved the beta and/or disagree with any of the aforementioned ramblings, I definitely mean no offense or think I know it all or anything like that and definitely respect other viewpoints. I get that it's difficult to make a game that'll appease everybody)
Your role as a moderator enables you immediately ban this user from messaging (bypassing the report queue) if you select a punishment.
7 Day Ban
7 Day Ban
30 Day Ban
Permanent Ban
This site uses cookies to provide you with the best possible user experience. By clicking 'Accept', you agree to the policies documented at Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.
Accept
This site uses cookies to provide you with the best possible user experience. By continuing to use this site, you agree to the policies documented at Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.
close
Our policies have recently changed. By clicking 'Accept', you agree to the updated policies documented at Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.
Accept
Our policies have recently changed. By continuing to use this site, you agree to the updated policies documented at Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.