{{
`${userDetail.user.displayName}${userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode ? `#${standardizeBungieGlobalCode(userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode)}` : ""}`}}
{{getUserClans()}}
Edited by Talia Sendua:
11/4/2016 11:55:52 AM
101
Who also wants back the HoW Weapon Reforgeing for Year 2/3 Weapons?
I think that HoW was the best weapon balance we got because of the reforgeing from weapons. Everyone has his own god roll weapon and noone was handycaped... Who wants it also back?!?
[b]Edit: Here is a good Suggestion from: Chris P Snipes[/b]
[quote]How about this concept:
You literally have a gunsmith in the tower and theres an armsday everyweek. So my idea is that you can hand 1 weapon per week to the gunsmith (the weapon will be gone till next armsday!!!) And the next part is where im not sure what would be the best:
A) he gives you a complete new random roll of the weapon
B) you can choose 1 perk that gets rolled
C) you give him another weapon that has that part. E.g. a scope. Lets say you got a decent sniper, but the scopes are bad so you give that sniper to the gunsmith and another legendary sniper that has the desired scope on it. (2nd sniper will be deleted in the progress) i mean hes a gunsmith - why wouldnt he be able to put one scope / perk onto another gun.
[/quote]
In my Opinion is 1 Weapon per week not enough for some Players (like me) but Restrictions like this goes in a Way which is ok and not really "gamebreaking".
If you have more Ideas write it into the Comments!
And before you complain about Shotguns, look at this Post from me (It is my Opinion):
[url]https://www.bungie.net/de/Forums/Post/217175520?sort=0&page=0[/url]
-
1 ReplyThe truth is everyone is using the same 10 guns anyway. Reforging would simply make each person be able to compete better vs others with it rather then losing to them just because they had high caliber rounds or such. HoW balanced weapons and is by far the best era imo. Plus it would reduce grinding time for that imago with outlaw/firefly and the like. I would love to see it come back.
-
No. Disagree.
-
2 RepliesEdited by BlueStar7217: 11/4/2016 1:34:15 PMFrankly, a lot of the naysayers appear to mistake reforging to be the villainous concept when in actuality they have a problem with specific guns. Be honest; do you guys really care what perks, say, Teacup Tempest or SUROS DIS-43 had? Or is it JUST guns like Matador that annoy you? As I recall, the only reforge rolls people complained about were for the Felwinter's Lie shotgun, the old Matador-64 shotgun, and the Efrideet's Spear sniper, primarily due to perks which have since been nerfed (Luck In The Chamber, Final Round) or removed entirely (Shot Package). Nobody cared how often people rerolled their Dr. Nope, Invisible Hand M7, LDR 5001, 77 Wizard, and so on. If reforging was brought back, I'd imagine people would complain about nothing but Matador and other high-range shotguns. A very small portion of weapons. Complain about specific guns if you absolutely must, fine, but don't put a blanket conclusion over everything. =/
-
5 RepliesThe thing about reforging is that everyone eventually gets a "God roll". In turn, this limits weapon variety and promotes the weapons with only the best base stats, like back ik HoW.
-
I agree. If this happens, people will be on the same level of playing field, no advantages to people with lucky drops.
-
Yea with all the weapons going round it might as well comeback then god rolled weapons won't get the small advantage they do get because everyone has it.
-
-
Bump, big time bump!
-
Thats an balanced and awesome idea yes please
-
1 ReplyI'd be happy to bring reforging back. I reforged a lot in year 1, had an insane hopscotch, Felwinters and spear. I understand the concern over everyone having max range matadors feeding the shotgun meta. I got lucky enough to get a God roll matador, but don't use it. Why? Because I also have a God roll wormwood and shotguns can't even get close. There's nothing better than taking down a shotgun warrior with a tiny pew pew gun. If I could reroll all my secondary weapons, I'd be even more inclined to diversify my loadouts. I'd love to use my saladin's Vigil, but without a perk to increase my charge rate, it'll likely become legendary marks in the future.
-
17 Replies[quote]I think that HoW was the best weapon balance we got because of the reforgeing from weapons. Everyone has his own god roll weapon and noone was handycaped... Who wants it also back?!? And before you complain about Shotguns[/quote] Why does a shotgun disclaimer even have to be a thing? Anyway, I'm mixed on it. Yes it would be good, as I have specific scouts I'm waiting for a fn specific roll on since January (Lydmilla-D), that will not give the roll I need to make it usable for me. However the increased "God" roll weapons will keep people from trying other weapons out (not like its actually happening anyway), which is not good (ESP with the way people complain about weapons on the forums.)
-
5 RepliesEdited by Drive By Pancakes: 11/4/2016 4:12:12 AMNo. Just no. I did not endure 2000 deaths from Efriwinter's Partydor just for you to bring back the stalest, dullest, most narrow minded meta in the game. Replace Thorn and TLW with grasp of malok or the clever dragon, and replace the three shotguns with LDR, 1kys, or any other high aa sniper, and it's basically the same thing, except slower.
-
1 ReplyHell no. This was a stupid idea. Half of the community are mindless zombies that only know how to follow what YouTubers or streamers say. That adds to a quicker copy and paste effect. Everyone would have the same guns with the same perks. No variety. That's completely fun isn't it?
-
1 Reply-blam!- no to reforging. It ruined year 1
-
Definitely would like it back instead of ranking up or decoding or opening a chest hoping I got a good roll on a weapon.
-
3 RepliesHow about this concept: You literally have a gunsmith in the tower and theres an armsday everyweek. So my idea is that you can hand 1 weapon per week to the gunsmith (the weapon will be gone till next armsday!!!) And the next part is where im not sure what would be the best: A) he gives you a complete new random roll of the weapon B) you can choose 1 perk that gets rolled C) you give him another weapon that has that part. E.g. a scope. Lets say you got a decent sniper, but the scopes are bad so you give that sniper to the gunsmith and another legendary sniper that has the desired scope on it. (2nd sniper will be deleted in the progress) i mean hes a gunsmith - why wouldnt he be able to put one scope / perk onto another gun. What do you think of that idea in general?
-
Edited by UFSman: 11/4/2016 10:41:24 AMBump just make it cost 100 marks at when we are not throwing away our rewards or guns which we have worked so hard to get.
-
Just do Iron banner and i heard its raining Pulse rifles. This Clever Dragon is nice.
-
BRING BACK REFORGING!!!!
-
3 RepliesInstead of reforging, I think Bungie should create a weapons mod system (with potential for crafting) like you see in the Division and Fallout 4. This could improve and expand the loot pool. If I got a weapons drop that I didn't really like overall, but it had a great mod on it that would greatly benefit another weapon that I do like, then that drop becomes desirable. Otherwise it just gets dismantled.
-
Edited by iDovahBear: 11/4/2016 2:33:53 AMI want Reforging back, but a revised system wouldn't hurt. But a system rigged to make both rolls worse than before is undesirable. Which is why I like the idea of only being able to change one perk at a time on a weekly lockout per-weapon. Not per-player, not per-account, just once per week on each individual weapon. That would be ideal. Including the Weaponsmith and Armsday would give them another dynamic to add for Banshee. Right now he's like useless scrap metal that happens to shell out a few menial supplies we're forced to buy when the game runs dry of them during gameplay or we end up overusing them. But I especially like being able to combine two misfit weapons with standalone 'god roll' perks into a Crucible-ready weapon that a player can feel they honestly worked for without just cheesing rerolls. I had for awhile tried to hold on to partially crappy rolls of Eyasluna hoping they would implement a weapon fusion/reforge function in Rise of Iron that capitalized on this sort of fusion system. But they never did. Even still it was nice being able to compare Eyasluna+Hammerforged+Rangefinder w/o a target acquisition scope against one with a target acquisition scope+Rifled Barrel but no Rangefinder. But being able to combine them would not only make sense, but it would still force a sort of grind prerequisite and the reality and lore of it makes sense. You have the parts, you just need to swap 'em.
-
23 Repliesya sure thats a good idea this way anyone with matador can get max range with rangefinder and then no one would use anything then shotty's thats a good idea kid.. lets screw up pvp worse then it is.. your definately special arent you
-
I want my VoG and Crota weapons back
-
1 Reply
-
BUMP. However, I think Bungie made some great steps in year 3 by removing crap perks like exhumed and last man standing from weapons. Look at RoI weapons on Planet Destiny. Not every roll is a God roll, but at least every roll is good.
-
Only if you have to wait until next arms-day to get the weapon back.
