So go to the opposite spectrum. Sunbreaker was heavily super based, yet was changed and nerfed due to it being to powerful. Why use Viking Funeral over longer duration? Thats up to you. The two perks would be equally viable now. People would needs to make decisions and can change their builds. Currently, if you're running Sunsinger without ToF/VF, you're doing it absolutely wrong. This change would promote different builds. Something Bungie stated explicitly when nerfing Sunbreaker (granted, they went overboard with it) was that one build was just way to viable and they want every class to have viable different builds. Well, viola. Here's the change that would work for Sunsinger.

So we make a perk a waste instead of making other perks better? That seems like an awful idea

I'll correct that for you bud: [quote] So we make a perk a waste in my eyes. [/quote] Free of charge this time mate. Anyway, "make a perk a waste" is quite the strong sentence. Considering everybody likes using it as it stands now, they just need to adapt slightly. Its not like we're changing anything about the perk. Just when the perk is active. And, if you're on about wasted perks, go look at Defender. Go look at Sunbreaker. Go look at Voidwalker and Nightstalker. Every class has its share of "wasted perks", or in real terms, less desirable than others. This change would not make this one useless. It, again, would promote using the super instead of saving it. You say the class is all neutral game based though... when it could be so much more. [b]You[/b] make it neutral game based. Super based, it's still a very strong super when combined with Radiant Skin. Add other things such as HOTPF or The Ram, and you can become devastating.