Scuf has more customization. It can be tailored specifically to your needs and provides potentially more "pro" features. However, scuf controllers really aren't built to last. The elite comes with the great quality you would expect, as well as a few easily adjustable features. It may not be the top of the line for customization, but it is definitely a great controller i would argue it is better Just for the fact it will last. It is also cheaper in comparison to a scuf controller with the same features. The worst part would be all of the different parts it comes with, which is awesome but could also be lost fairly easily I imagine. Though it does come with a carrying case so that hopefully shouldn't be an issue. Gotta go with the elite. Scuf just doesn't have the quality. Unless you just want the best of the best features, elite wins.