originally posted in:The Ashen Conflux
Welcome, one and all, to my analysis of the possibility of a new Fallen House in the Destiny Universe. To begin, allow me to list the Houses that we currently know of:
+Devils- Kell, Archon, and Prime Servitor destroyed.
+Kings- Kell, Archon, and Prime Servitor unknown.
+Exiled*- No leadership.
+Winter- Kell destroyed, Prime Servitor and Archon found only in Grimoire.
+Wolves- Kell(s) destroyed, Prime Servitor destroyed (multiple times), Archon destroyed (that Public Event on Mars)
+Judgement- Only surviving member is Variks, a House scribe
+Rain- eradicated(?): in charge of prophecies and maintaining order.
*note: Exiled is not a House recognized by the Fallen: it is a group of disgraced Fallen who have formed their own House.
The last three Houses on this list were brought to the attention of the Destiny community with the House of Wolves Expansion. The Wolves are fought directly, Judgement aids you in your quest, and Rain is mentioned in the margins of Grimoire and Quest descriptions.
With the arrival of the Taken King Expansion, however, there have been rumors of a new Fallen House, which may or may not be present within the game. The greatest source of data regarding this "new House" is found in the King's Fall Raid weapons, specifically the Doom of Chelchis Scout rifle, which I shall be focusing on for this analysis.
The scout rifle, which is adorned in the style of the Oryx Raid (spiky bone and marrow) gives the following description:
"Where is the Great Machine? Where is the Great Machine?" -Chelchis, Kell of Stone.
Fallen lore-hounds will likely notice the reference to the Great Machine, which was what the Fallen called the Traveler when it resided on their homeworld. This sets the timeframe for this quote: before or during the Whirlwind (the Fallen's version of the Collapse), on the Eliksni (Fallen) homeworld, just after the Traveler's sudden departure.
Focus on the speaker: Chelchis, Kell of Stone. This is where much of the debate regarding this new House has originated. Many have argued that because Chelchis is the Kell of Stone, there must be a Fallen House of Stone. Well, not necessarily.
Here's what we do know: Chelchis is a true Kell. Kell's names tend to end in an -is, as is seen through Draxis (Winter Kell, killed by you) and Solkis (Devil Kell, killed by Saint-14). The only exceptions to this rule are the Kells of the Wolves, which end in -as (e.g. Skolas and Virixas). So, due to Chelchis's name, and his title of Kell, we can discern that Chelchis is, in fact, an actual Kell.
However, is Chelchis the Kell over the House of Stone -- furthermore, is there a House of Stone? To determine this, we'll need to delve into the most interesting subject of all time: grammar!
We have only technically encountered two Kells in the playable world of Destiny: Draxis and Skolas. These Kells, and their titles, will be instrumental in determining the existence of the House of Stone.
For starters, let's look at Draxis. As seen in this picture here, Draksis's title is listed as follows: "Draksis, Winter Kell." Hold on to this piece of information before I make my big reveal.
Now, let's take a quick look at Skolas. As seen in this picture here, Skolas's title is listed as follows: "Skolas, Kell of Kells."
Look at Skolas's title: even though he technically gave it to himself, it is a legitimate title from Fallen lore: a title of honor. That said, Skolas is not the Kell of the House of Kells: the phrase "Kell of Kells" is used to describe his attributes -- it can be interpreted as "the Kell over all Kells."
Now look back at Draksis's title. Draksis, who is the Kell over the House of Winter, has the title "Winter Kell." Not "Kell of Winter." Judging from this comparison, the official title for the Kell over a House is " Name, House Kell," not " Name, Kell of House." Because, again, Skolas is not the Kell of the House of Kells, but Draxis is the Kell of the House of Winter.
Finally, apply this general grammatical tool to Chelchis, Kell of Stone. His title follows the Skolas outline, meaning it is a description of him, rather than a statement of his position in a House. His name reads as "Chelchis, Kell who is like Stone," not "Chelchis, Kell of the House of Stone." It's kind of like how Margaret Thatcher is known as the "Iron Lady;" she's a Lady steadfast like Iron, and Chelchis is a Kell steadfast as Stone.
Because "Kell of Stone" is a description of Chelchis's attributes, not his leadership over a House, there is no proof of there actually being a House of Stone.
All this does is raise more questions, however. What is the full nature of Fallen politics? What was Chelchis actually the Kell of? Personally, I think Chelchis was a high-Kell of some sort: not necessarily the Kell of Kells, but basically the head of all the Fallen. Imagine the Speaker, but for Fallen. This would explain why his question of "Where is the Great Machine?" is more important than the questions of any other Fallen: he is important, and therefore, his words have impact.
Let me know what you think of this analysis in the comments. Throw your own theories out there: get thinking, make theories, etc. Heck, I invite you to disprove my theory, as long as it gets the conversation flowing.
TL;DR: Chelchis was a stone-like Kell, but there is no House of Stone.
Note: I already created this thread on another lore clan page, but that clan is... inactive to say the least. Please enjoy, and don't sue me for plagiarism or whatever.
-
Kell of Stone, not Kell of stone, he capitalization of the word stone is actually the only solid thing we can say, your argument of "-as" "-is" can be quickly debunked, Kharris is an Archon, not even a fully fledged Archon if we're to assume that's what he was rising to be. There's also Niksis, a simple Baron, and Riksis another Archon.
-
Kell of Stone, not Kell of stone, he capitalization of the word stone is actually the only solid thing we can say, your argument of "-as" "-is" can be quickly debunked, Kharris is an Archon, not even a fully fledged Archon if we're to assume that's what he was rising to be. There's also Niksis, a simple Baron, and Riksis another Archon.
-
Kell of Stone, not Kell of stone, he capitalization of the word stone is actually the only solid thing we can say, your argument of "-as" "-is" can be quickly debunked, Kharris is an Archon, not even a fully fledged Archon if we're to assume that's what he was rising to be. There's also Niksis, a simple Baron, and Riksis another Archon.
-
I remember something in the House of Wolves quest line description saying there were thousands, maybe hundreds of thousands, of houses before the Whirlwind. They all got rekt by Oryx and the hive. There probably was a House of Stone that was annihilated after its Kell was killed. It would make sense in my mind for there to be that many houses. If you look at the Grimoire, the House of Wolves numbered in the millions before the pwnage of Ceres. If that was around the normal size of an eliksni house during the Whirlwind, there must have had to be several thousand houses if the Eliksni population was large enough for the Traveller to think they could stand up to the hive. I mean, Humanity could have been up to 8 or 9 billion before the Traveller sets down on Mars. We could have gotten to 12-20 billion before the Collapse, and look how badly we did against the hive. The hive have been a scourge upon the universe since before Earth was formed. That's nearly 13.4 billion years of slaughtering every species the Traveller thought could stand up against the hive's might. The Traveller had to have become somewhat experienced in chosing races to help it fight the Darkness by the time it got to the Eliksni. The had to be either in the billions in population or pretty damn good at fighting for the Traveller to have thought they stood a chance. If you've played Destiny for any decent amount of time, you know that the fallen are not good at fighting us or the hive. So, they must have had one hell of a population for the Traveller to deem them worthy of its gifts. Contradict me, please. I like to see the many opinions in the Destiny universe.
-
Edited by Halo vortex 200: 2/17/2016 11:06:43 PMFrom the Grimrore we have learned that chelchis was the kell of the house of stone and that he was killed by oryx during the whirlwind (when the hive invaded the eliksni homeworld).he is described as "a warrior of the light". Soon after chelchis was killed the house of stone was annihilated.
-
Blump
-
Trump
-
Two things. First, take a look at Ghost Fragment: Hunter [quote]She leaves the rifle and walks across the naked obsidian into the swarm firing from the hip as she goes, each kick of the old revolver a word, Draksis, Draksis, Kell of Winter, Kell of hate, lord of the kingdom of her vendetta. Her jaw aches. She used to imagine biting out his throat with armored teeth.[/quote] ________ Kell and Kell of ________ seem to be interchangeable. Second, there's a Warlock Artifact called a Broken Crown. It's flavor text reads "Eliksni songs still tell of Chelchis, Kell of Stone, who stood before the Maw." Could this crown have been Chelchis'?
-
Edited by Ziggerastica: 11/2/2015 11:05:30 PMCan i point out one tiny flaw? We also killed devils next archon. Its a kill the target patrol beacon mission
-
Fantastic post, I learned a lot about the Eliksni. Keep up the good work.
-
https://www.bungie.net/en/Forum/Post/167604227/0/0
-
Great theory! One loophole I've found is that I've heard through the grapevine that variks says "does the great machine speak to you, as it once spoke to me?" I see this as judgement being the 'council of speakers' as the only way that would work.
-
I'm writing a nerdy fan-fiction about this. I will take this knowledge/theory and apply to my fan-fiction. Credit to you good sir
-
-
Chelchis is kinda like a prophecy/religious kinda guy. I read somewhere that he had like a song and the fallen sing that song in remembrance
-
I've been wondering about this for some time.
-
Kell of kell's means he is Kell of all other kells which is what skolas would have ruled. Now draksis ruled the winter eliskni so he is Kell of winter. Stone was probably just an old house from a time after the whirl wind. That was soon gobbled up by oryx. now the queen may have survived the blast so if so then the techeun weapons are out of place. I am sure I had a point but yeah.
-
That was a good read. I wonder however if the naming was just a mistake on Bungie part. I like your theory though and I definitely believe it is likely. Now I want to see some more lore concerning chelchis...