Mine probably would have been Borderlands 2, but I'm not sure.
EDIT: The Walking Dead is also a possibility.
What about you Septagonians?
-
Easily Borderlands 2. Every complaint I had in the first one was almost completely removed from the second one, IMO. Forza Horizon is coming very close though. I just got it last week and all of my gaming time has been going into it since then. A great racing game, and one that I had very few expectations for.