{{
`${userDetail.user.displayName}${userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode ? `#${standardizeBungieGlobalCode(userDetail.user.cachedBungieGlobalDisplayNameCode)}` : ""}`}}
{{getUserClans()}}
9/8/2015 12:28:32 PM
67
Halo lore: WE HAVE INFINITE EVERYTHING AND PRE DATE THE UNIVERSE
star wars lore: WE ACTUALLY USE SCIENCE, HAVE OVER FIFTY YEARS OF MATERIAL but wait oh nvm [b][i][u]DISNEY RUINED IT[/u][/i][/b]
Still tho you want to get into preoccupations of infinity and time space? Star Wars has JUST AS MUCH infinity potential as halo: its called THE FORCE as far as time/space and dimensions, same junk can be speculated.
Also for the BILLIONTH TIME Halo Array ONLY works on NON SHIELDED LIFE FORMS LARGER THAN 2mm IN the SAME space time dimension in ONE galaxy AND TAKES DAYS TO FIRE!
The star wars universe IS larger than ONE galaxy btw AND both HALO and STARWARS actually take place [u][i][b]IN THE SAME UNIVERSE[/b][/i][/u]
English
-
mate your going to start an actuall nerd war
-
Had a few but yea
-
It's fiction. The halo rings can do what the lore says, not what is realistic.
-
Well then this whole argument is MUTE cuz halo jus makes junk up while star wars actually tries now a days to put science behind everything. So of course the one where u can make up anything and do everything to infinity is gonna bloody win
-
Science and realism don't matter. Only lore matters.
-
And if your lore ignores the laws of physics you can make anything do anything you want period with out limit.
-
Halo is confined by its lore. That's where its limitations come from. The same can be said for star wars. Halo isn't reality, so only a moron would complain that it isn't confined to the rules of reality.
-
Halo by the lore takes place in the future IN THIS UNIVERSE, star wars in the lore takes place IN THE PAST in THIS universe; [u][i][b]BOTH MUST OBEY THIS UNIVERSE's LAWS OF PHYSICS[/b][/i][/u] SORRY but explain how the 2 statements i made in this reply are false
-
And star wars does this how? With magic? Makes sense.
-
Magic regarding what? The force is manipulation of energy in the universe using mediclorians as conduits to manipulate that energy; Energy forms that exist: Heat/thermal Electric Magnetic Sonic Photonics(light waves) And ANY BAND OF FREQUENCY on the electromagnetic spectrum that is not listed above.
-
I could explain anything in halo, then, if we can be that vague.
-
Halo array bast wave speed and energy type cant be explained. Even that vague. Also that IS the explanation in star wars lore on HOW the force works.
-
The forerunners utilize slipspace rifts to send energy across galaxies instantly. Bam, done. That is, of course, implying the halo rings need to follow the real rules, which they don't. They exist as they do in their universe, therefore the rules of their universe must be such that the halo rings can exist as they do. It doesn't need to follow the rules of reality because it isn't real. I'm not sure why you can't comprehend this.
-
An energy burst if traveling thru slip space is not traveling through our universe air go can not effect anything within our universe until it arrives at its destination; You see why i said each particle would need to know exactly where and when it was going to hit its target if it used slipspace to get there?
-
So? They send many of them out at all different trajectories and across a variety of distances. This is easy stuff.
-
Not when you take TIME into account. The halo rings ONLY destroy life in the galaxy AFTER the halos are fired; if they use slipspace to get to their targets that means EACH halo must direct each particle of the blast to a specific TIME AND SPACE within the universe AND at all times each Halo must know WHERE EVERY SINGLE life form within its radius is! Its not that sophisticated!
-
It doesn't have to know where each one is. It just has to hit every possible spot. Piece of cake.
-
Not really, sub space is OUTSIDE this universe so ANY blast wave moving through subspace HAS NO effect on our universe. Hence if using subspace (a point A to B only travel method) it needs to know where to go before going there
-
So they hit every spot in the universe through a series of waves. This isn't complicated.
-
Cept that would require somethin like 1/2 the energy in the universe to do; not to mention that they dont do that, they only wipe life from ONE galaxy and life only inhabits less than 1% area coverage of a galaxy.
-
Your math?
-
Edited by DarthBrando: 9/12/2015 4:31:00 AMLess than 1% of galaxy is inhabited: Only 2/3 of the systems in a galaxy are in safe livable galactic zones (not in the galactic core: too much cosmic radiation there, not in nebulae: waaay to hot there, not in systems with giant stars: too much solar radiation, ect...) Out of the remaining 1/3 of the galaxy by our estimates 1 in 500 to 1500 of systems have an m class planet capable of supporting life. Thats 200,000,000 to 600,000,000 possible planets capable of supporting life out of several TRILLION (thats already at 0.2%-0.6% of ALL galactic star systems(systems in our galaxy)) let alone area of that galaxy covered by life forms. On earth life forms inhabit 0.000009% to 2% of the entire planet's area (all atmosphere included) Now to blanket all areas of the universe at once means you need to cover that entire area with what ever SUB ATOMIC particles the halo array uses. SUB atomic particles are extremely small (not that much energy to create) but the amount you need to cover 1 CUBIC METER is already something like 1,000 TRILLION x10^40 Thats 1,000 trillion with 40 extra zeros and thats just one cubic [u][i][b]METER[/b][/i][/u] that bein said; heres how BIG the universe is: Earth is to the milky way (our galaxy) what ONE ATOM is to EARTH. The milky way is to the observable universe what one electron is to the size of the earth. The observable universe is to the universe what one atom is to our solar system. So its so ridiculously large we literally cant comprehend it or build a computer powerful enough to compute its size+ everything in it on a true 1 to 1 life sized scale (the entire universe not just the observable) The observable universe is something like 36x BILLION light years in every direction from our solar system out; An to the actual size of the universe the observable universe's 72 billion light year diameter is only what a SINGLE ATOM represents within the space of our ENTIRE SOLAR SYSTEM. So yea if u wanted to blanket ALL the universe with sub atomic particles YOU NEED more than HALF THE ENERGY IN THE [u][i][b]ENTIRE UNIVERSE[/b][/i][/u] to do it.
-
Less than 1% of the galaxy is inhabited by life? How do you know how much life is in the galaxy? Did you count? I doubt it [spoiler]I doubt we can accurately calculate how much life there is if we haven't even discovered other life yet.[/spoiler]
-
So now you're saying the rings fire subatomic particles? Before it was energy. Make up your mind.
-
Dude, you need to give up. You are way outclassed here.
![[CuCh] Seagebs](/img/profile/avatars/a_reach_13.gif?cv=3983621215&av=1897492508)
