Absolutely perfect, have long suspected the same as the results suggest, and yet I do play a Warlock often in PvP. Why? Because once in a while, when a Warlock melee is perfect... it is a beautiful thing to behold, and... rest assured the receiver of that once in a while flawless melee... results in not only death to the character... but the yelling and screaming of the player that is on the receiving end... is in a word... priceless.