This really can't be argued. You are correct. A player right now will have to re-purchase what they already own to acquire the same things a new player will acquire. This is completely illogical and indefensible. I can buy the Taken King DLC but a new buyer gets all that and more for a cheaper price. It doesn't make any sense in any way at all. Anything they give to newcomes should automatically be given to old players as well. ATLEAST it should be even.