My friend did the nightfall on his first time and.... HE GOT THE FCKING GJALLY AND I GOT STRANGE COINS, what a good luck...
-
I know how you feel. Carried a buddy of mine through nightfall and his reward was a Gjallarhorn. After he leveled it up he started to ignore me, and now I don't even play with him but once a month at best. Goes to show that you don't get anything for being nice.