Hello everyone! First I want to start by saying [b]absolutely no weapon should be nerfed.[/b] I just needed to catch your attention.
That said I do have a solution for both sides of this ridiculous controversy over thorn and other exotics. First we know that auto rifles need a buff. All of them, not just suros and especially necrochasm. This will level the playing field in the existing crucible as it is right now.
My second solution, the one that's going to cater towards the crybabies, is to introduce a new crucible playlist. Think of barebones in Cod. In this game mode ALL exotics are disabled (including gear as well). The rest of the mechanics can be in place as no one is complaining about those too much. That way if you hate thorn so much, you don't have to see a single one (or any exotic for that matter) in BB.
This would actually be a cool game mode because the skill would really show just by using legendaries and blues.
I welcome feedback on this idea and what could be done to improve it. Just a suggestion that can make everyone happy.
Edit: thanks for replys guys keep em coming!! also it has been pointed out to me that SOME weapons (namely the vex and other fusions) needed recent nerfs. I can agree with that(slightly because i still lack the vex and its one of the few weapons that kick my ass in pvp). fusions probably still need tweaking because only the plug one.1 with rangefinder is a viable option in pvp and thats only one fusion. Plan c is nice though too.
-
How about mods with +resistance to hand cannon/autos/etc on armor?
-
[quote] Thorn wouldn't be so op if I wasn't as fast as the last word and hit as hard as hawkmoon lol and it has damage over time [/quote] This ^
-
Nice ideas...but you'd still have complaining. Because different level and gear-based perks. Some FPS gamers simply have egos that are too fragile to admit that sometimes the other guy is just BETTER....so they will always complain that the game is "not fair" whenever they lose.
-
So....J Ward could of won that gunfight if he just took cover and sat his azz down.Hindsight is 20/20.
-
I like it!
-
Edited by THE COUNT DANTE: 5/5/2015 12:32:29 PMThorn is fine and beatable, even by crappy players. How do I know? I have beat thorn. I, am crappy. TLW needs the range enforced and the ADS bug fixed. End of balance list.
-
-
Edited by gr1zzlar: 5/5/2015 9:11:43 AMThorn doesn't need a nerf, it's not that bad as it's made it to be. All weapons were not created equally. That's part of the allure of the game. Each weapon archetype has its own pros and cons. Within each archetype there is a variance to the weapons. This gives a wide possible range of uses. Additionally, some weapons are actually earned in this game. These weapons should be better than the rest, as it is an incentive to earn them. Now, each weapon also has its own counter. Thorn for example is only as skillful as the hands that wield it. It is easily countered with pulse rifles and scouts rifles, meaning mid to long range. In close quarters your fusion and shotguns dominate it, as well as auto rifles. Auto rifles do not need a buff, they are actually quite powerful if you play to their strengths. This means you should be using an auto rifle in more of close quarters areas. Most pulse rifles take 5 shots to the body, and takes longer to kill when doing. If you stopped trying to use an auto rifle like a scout rifle, meaning across the map, you'd be perfectly contempt with its abilities in short ranges. Fusion rifles, I don't have much of an opinion on as I hardly ever have used one, it's not my style. Overall, the weapons are closer to balanced than they have been since launch. If you play to how each archetype was designed, and counter accordingly, there shouldn't be much of an issue. Edit - I forgot to mention, that new game type. That is interesting, but I don't think that viable option to eliminate exotics from being used. Removing supers seems more feasible, instead of trying to block a large portion of content in the game.
-
Edited by Grim Abstract: 5/5/2015 12:39:56 AMThorn wouldn't be so op if I wasn't as fast as the last word and hit as hard as hawkmoon lol and it has damage over time so there's that... Lol buff auto rifles and you'll see more people using them over thorn.
-
Are you nuts ? or are you high ? Please go and play cod, you have no idea what are you talking about kid !
-
If you don't have an exotic hand cannon you're at a disadvantage. Yes there are counters but if I get thorn/TLW I'll scrape kids
-
http://www.sirlin.net/articles/playing-to-win For the scrubs asking for nerfs.
-
How to Fix Thorn: 1: Find whiners 2: Kill whiners 3: Bath in Whiner tears & blood 4: ??? 5: Profit
-
Man, use white space. Break up that wall of text. Make the paragraphs top heavy, with the most important point up front. Then move on to the next point below.
-
[quote]First I want to start by saying [b]absolutely no weapon should be nerfed.[/b] [/quote] When you say this do you mean that under no circumstances should a weapon ever be nerfed? Or do you simply mean at this current time no weapons need to be nerfed. If it's the former then I wholeheartedly disagree. OG Mythoclast for example... [quote] My second solution, the one that's going to cater towards the crybabies, is to introduce a new crucible playlist. Think of barebones in Cod. In this game mode ALL exotics are disabled (including gear as well). [/quote] This would be a good idea. I've been hoping for a mode like this since release. Sadly it would probably be a nightmare for Bungie to implement given the way their system is set up.
-
Nerfing thorn seems to be a big thing on the forums now. I saw a poll earlier that asked if people wanted a thorn nerf, and the overwhelming majority i think said no? Just sharing that bit of info
-
I think an autorifle buff would go a long way toward remedying the situation. I can understand the frustration of people who don't have thorn, tlw, or hawkmoon. They are very powerful weapons that are difficult to match in a straight shootout. An AR buff would give these people something to counter with. I'm afraid the people who own these guns and call them crutches for noobs (while using them themselves) will never be satisfied though.
-
Edited by Adam: 5/5/2015 2:36:28 AM[quote] First I want to start by saying absolutely no weapon should be nerfed[/quote] Dumbest shit I've heard.
-
That would be cool