originally posted in:Collective Of Knowledge
[b]*I will ask a series of questions, and you may try to answer them. I don't know the answers myself. You may also ask your own questions, which I, or other commenters may try to answer*[/b]
[b]1) What would happen we place Vex radiolarian cells inside a living creature?[/b]
We know it infects, causes hallucicanations, and lead to "spiritual" experiences. Would it have any long term effects? Would the hallucinations have any meaning behind them?
[quote]The cellular Vex elements are infectious, hallucinogenic, entheogenic. (Ghost Fragment: Vex 4)[/quote]
[b]2) What would we find if we sequenced the genomes of the Hive's worms? same for the Vex cells.[/b]
We know Ahamkara genomes have been sequenced, and they're supposedly pretty weird. How would the worm genomes compare to Ahamkara genomes, given their physical similarities and other connections? For Vex cells, they might have genomes made of some exotic molecules in structures different than familiar double helixes (the worms/Ahamkara might also), but what if they actually have the same type of genome we're familiar with on Earth?
[quote]We were there for the Ahamkara, parasitic reptilian critters that appeared out of thin air. Inexplicable genome. New proteins. So much potential. ([url=https://www.reddit.com/r/DestinyTheGame/comments/3kxclc/spoilers_inside_caydes_treasure_island_notes/]Cayde's writings[/url])[/quote]
[quote]The living creatures themselves, we found a hundred meters down. They might have been worms, if worms had scales and teeth and moved more quickly than a man could run.
[...]
There is no returning to what you were before: a believer of science, and the fundamental rationality of the universe. Not after seeing those worms. (Ghost Fragment: The Ocean of Storms 2)[/quote]
[b]3) Could we gain powers or knowledge from the Darkness by reading Oryx's Tablets of Ruin?[/b]
The Tablets are full of secrets obtained by Oryx from when he killed the worm god Akka. The Tablets allow him to speak to the Darkness, and that is how the Darkness gave him the power of Taking. We encounter the Tablets of Ruin when fighting Golgoroth. I'd love to read them and see what happens... or maybe have someone else do it, and watch from a safe distance.
[quote]Auryx the First Navigator set upon his god with his sword and his words, and cut Akka to pieces, and took from those pieces the secret of calling upon the Deep. He wrote this secret on a set of tablets, which he called the Tablets of Ruin. And he wore them about his waist.
Then Auryx said, “Now I may speak to the Deep, the beautiful final shape. I will be King of Shapes. I will learn all the secrets of our destiny.”
If we directed our worship to the worms of the dreadnaught? How much more powerful could we get while inside the dreadnaught, or other Hive throne worlds? (Verse 3:8 — King of Shapes)[/quote]
[b]4) If those of us who achieved godhood in a Hive throne world died in regular space without a ghost to revive us, would we be reborn in the throne world like a Hive god?[/b]
The symbiotic worms living inside the Hive not only make them immortal, but allow them to get more and more power as they kill other living things. This is called sword logic. The laws of physics and causality can be broken with sufficient sword logic, and they can do amazing things like cutting holes through space itself, and creating throne worlds which pocket universes forged by their minds which they return to when they die. They can keep coming back unless they're killed in their throne world. We don't have worms, but the rules of sword logic is a physical law inside throne worlds, and that allows us to become a gods by killing gods. If you killed both Oryx, then you are a god, because you have the sword logic of killing him. So the question is, if you did not make a throne world, but you have become a god there by gaining the necessary sword logic, would you be reborn there upon death if your ghost does not revive you?
[quote]You are no longer bound by causal closure. Your will defeats law. Kill a hundred of your children with a long blade, Auryx, and observe the change in the blade. Observe how the universe shrinks from you in terror. (Verse 2:6 — The Sword Logic)[/quote]
[quote]Your body is gone, but you have endured. Safe in the cyst universe created by your own might — your throne world.
From this day forward, Auryx, you and your sisters will each survive death — so long as you aren’t killed in your own throne. (Verse 2:7 — The Weakness Verse)[/quote]
[quote]The Vex clattered around, constructing large problems. At first their constructions were deranged, because they didn’t understand the sword logic, which defined all rules in Oryx’s throne world. The geometry perplexed them. (Verse 4:9 — open your eye : go into it)[/quote]
[quote]it set about abducting and killing dangerous organisms so it could bootstrap itself to Hive godhood. (Verse 4:9 — open your eye : go into it)[/quote]
[b]5) Would worshiping worms outside of a throne world give us powers to bend reality?[/b]
We know that worshipping worms give you powers to alter reality, but does it only work in throne worlds?
[quote]By directing worship at the worms, Quria learned it could alter reality with mild ontopathogenic effects. Being an efficient machine, Quria manufactured a priesthood and ordered all its subminds to believe in worship. (Verse 4:9 — open your eye : go into it)[/quote]
[b]6) What would we find if we chemically analyze Eliksni (Fallen) ether?[/b]
What would you find? Ether was everywhere in the planet that they came from, but it can't just be a simple gas like oxygen, it has to be very complex with many kind of molecules involved given that it acts as food for them. What sort of planet has such complex gases?
[quote]Remember the hope that brought us here. Remember the age before the Whirlwind, when ether ran free, when we ruled ourselves and our futures as kings. We wanted more than glimmer and glints and herealways. Always remember that we came to this star in hope. And remember that we were denied! Remember the City of the Death of Children, the City That Docks, which claimed for itself the Great Machine that might have saved us. Remember the City that even now sends its ghouls to murder our Primes, starve our ether, and leave our young to die gasping. Curse that City and its name. The curse is just. (Ghost Fragment: Fallen 3)[/quote]
[b]7) What's the deal with harbingers?[/b]
Do they have physical forms? How did they first came to be? They are the balls of energy summoned by queen Mara Sov and her techeuns in the battle against Oryx. They manipulate gravity and attracted space debris to strike the dreadnaught. The weird thing is they are alive, they are minds, and they can reproduce by being planted in dead things. They are also some kind of trophy taken from an "ageless war." I have my own theories on the subject, but I am far from sure, and there's still many questions even if I'm right.
[quote]Harbinger Minds they kept here, trophies from an ageless war, and weapons in the right hands. (The Coven)[/quote]
[quote]The Harbingers, which to prepare?” [...] “All but one, the oldest. It stays with us. Sedia, Kalli, Shuro, take the children, tell her they are to be planted into a dead thing to have children of their own.” (The Coven)[/quote]
[b]8) Why didn't the Vex time-loop Quria to make him stronger than Oryx?[/b]
In question 4, I explained Hive sword logic, and how you can exploit it to become a god in a Hive throne world. The Vex did this when Crota was tricked into cutting a portal in Oryx's throne world, allowing them to invade (hence why Crota was exiled). Quria, a Vex mind, failed to beat Oryx, but I think he should have been able to very easily. Quria kills thousands of Hive to gain the sword logic and become a powerful god. Quria could go back in time to right before it killed those Hive, and repeat the process as a way to iteratively increase his sword logic.
[b]9) What are the keyhole structures at A-113? What is the eye reported inside it?[/b]
Dead Orbit found a station orbiting Ceres. They then found a series of structures like keyholes that go on for thousands of kilometers. Those that went inside the structures screamed in horror, and reported seeing some kind of eye.
[quote]We abandoned the Sophia one-point-five days ago. We jumped ship for A-113.
I don't know what else to call it. I don't know what it was built for. There are these things, like keyholes. The rangefinders say they go on for thousands of kilometers. The others went inside and found - well, some of them are still screaming about the eye. All the other voices that come back are more terrible. (Ghost Fragment: Dead Orbit)[/quote]
[b]10) How do Awoken reproduce?[/b]
There are many references to Awoken being born, yet the Eliksni say they are infertile. Given that Awoken are humans bonded to some sort of foreign entity, I would assume that Awoken use some kind of magic to make more of this foreign entity and bind them to humans (perhaps dead people, considering the inspiration for Awoken include angels and vampires). Were the first earthborn Awoken made during the collapse like those of the Reef? I can only guess, so what do you guys think?
[quote]Inside me was an essence woven from beyond. Was I Awoken before this? (Ghost Fragment: Awoken 3)[/quote]
[quote]Others were present at my birth.
A great ceremony had just begun. Because newborns are selfish beasts, I assumed I was the object of attention. (Ghost Fragment: Awoken 2)[/quote]
[quote]Earthborn Awoken who venture out to the Reef, hoping to learn its secrets, (Awoken)[/quote].
[b]For theories by me, I refer you to the [url=https://www.bungie.net/en/Forum/Post/183288968/0/0]Collected Treatises of The Warlock KAGEHOSHI[/url].[/b]
-
*casts True Ressurection* I'm particularly interested in the Awoken reproduction thing and the Harbingers.
-
What determines the class a Guardian is? We know that there are three classes and we can choose one of them for the sake of gameplay, but what actually determines a class lore-wise? Also, why are only Warlocks the scholars? I understand that they have the superior intellect, but surely there are some Titans that strive to understand the nature of their enemies and the Darkness and some Warlocks that don't care about the knowledge and only care about winning the fight.
-
Edited by Deskbound: 2/3/2016 12:49:40 PM6) Ether is an organic compound containing carbon, oxygen and hydrogen. It was used medically as the first inhaled general anaesthetic agent and ethyl groups (as opposed to the specific ethyl compound normally known as "ether") are very commonly found throughout biochemistry as common components of carbohydrates. Some planets and moons in our solar system are thought to have atmospheres and oceans made of organic compounds. An atmosphere of gaseous ether on some distant exoplanet is probably not beyond the realms of possibility and if life had evolved there, who's to say that it wouldn't use atmospheric organic molecules as nutrition rather than eating and digesting other organisms as a source of carbon as we do. No idea about the rest though.
-
Question 1 made me wonder if we ever had any concrete description of the substances Future War Cult are using to instigate their "visions"? Some of the effects and experiences they describe are very similar to those caused by Vex radiolarian cells; is it possible that they are a part of FWC's ritual? If so, adherents may be influenced by a Vex interpretation of the future, rather than an objective viewing of it.
-
9: Sounds like Vex structures, from the shape and scale. The eyes could possibly ([i]possibly[/i]) be Oracles, implying a second "Vault of Glass like" structure.
-
8: Vex logic and Hive logic don't mix. No matter how many times Quaria "looped," it would never gain the appropriate knowledge required to defeat Oryx without [i]direct[/i] contact with a Dark Worm. As for why it didn't loop anyway, Quaria is a unit in a great machine: self-preservation is not a factor. It is likely that such a loop [i]is[/i] occurring (in the past), and a constant area of Vex are being sent through time at Oryx, to no avail.
-
7: The Harbringers are likely the embodiment of some great power outside the edges of our solar system. It is clear their origin is outside the Jovian line: whether they are related to the Nine is unclear. What we do know is that there is one remaining (the oldest), and they can be weaponized (Telesto, Opening TTK cutscene).
-
5: First we would have to find a Worm, devote ourselves to it, and absorb its essence (like the Sisters did). But otherwise, Worm worship is palpable anywhere in the Universe, so long as you are able to give them tribute through Worms of your own. After a while, the only possible way to give enough to the Worms is to have a Throne World, but that's besides the point.
-
4: The simple answer: no. If you remember in the Book of Sorrows, the only reason the Throne Worlds allow Hive gods to revive there is because the Deathsingers hid the god's death there. The Throne World itself does not establish the god's life force: however, the magic and knowledge of the Deathsingers, who can literally hide the death of gods within things (see: Oversould, Deathsinger's Song, Throne Worlds). Ergo, unless we used Hive magic to hide our deaths within the Throne World we have conquered, our souls are not bound to the World, and therefore, we will not return there on death.
-
3: This is an interesting concept: however, I fear it does not go very far. I view the Tablets of Ruin very similar to the Deathsinger's Song. The act of "reading" it is to simply "transcend understanding:" basically, it kills you, similar to the Deathsinger's song. This is why there is a forced wipe after a certain number of deaths in the Golgoroth fight: each death corresponds with the Tablet's Dark energy, in essence, "reading it." When the Tablet is completely "read," everyone dies, as the full meaning of the Tablet, which is the embodiment of death, is realized. However, it would be intriguing if a great scholar could interpret the Tablet, as Toland interpreted the Deathsinger's song.
-
I'm gonna go through these as I see them: I'm on mobile, so that's one comment at a time. For number 1, I believe this question has already been explored to some extent through multiple different angles. Remember the FWC's infamous "machine," which produces largely the same results as the ones described in the effects of Vex cells. If correlation proves true, that would mean the FWC machine incorporates Vex technology, and suggests that Vex tech can be utilized to warp/view timelines. Additionally, the escapade of Doctor Shim and his focus group (which presumably included the human minds of the Exo Stranger and Cayde-6, if current theories are to be believed) again highlights the integration of Vex technology with organic matter. While the fusion takes place within the hypothetical world of a Vex simulation, the results are the same: hundreds of accurate, data-clones. Ergo, similar to the 343 Halo series's Composer, it is possible that Vex technology creates a data-version of an organic form, which can be thrust through Vex timelines to see the future/past/alternate realities, and, assuming the correct measures are taken, transposed back into their human hosts (with high rates of complications).
-
Edited by moka: 1/14/2016 1:05:22 AMI have a theory were awoken are formed from two separate souls in one body, the original awoken were created when a cataclysmic event where the travelers light and the darkness collided which was at the asteroid belt where all the humans who had fled earth where, and that's how the awoken were born as to how new awoken awoken are born I'm not entirely sure, your guess is probably better than mine. And when the grimiore or anything references earth born awoken it means guardians. You see after a time when the awoken had established their society some felt like they needed to help the last city and earth, this was a time before guardians the dark age, and so many awoken journeyed to earth and some passed away on earth so when you come back as a Guardian it's sort of like a metaphorical/literal new birth hence earth born.
-
I read like 7 words...
-
Edited by A Rising Wind: 1/14/2016 8:23:50 PM9). Other than being an Easter egg for Pixar. I think A-113 acts like a vex gate to teleport people who enter the key holes (ie: go on for thousands of kilometers) I haven't decided which it is, but the keyholes I believe either teleport to hive throne worlds where the "eye" is the oversoul (which is referred to in other grimoire as resembling an eye). The keyhole shape is similar to the shape of the entrance to Crotas throne world in the raid from the abyss. Or the keyholes teleport to the shrine of Oryx on the moon. The story mission in the shrine of oryx where the big Saturn looking device is talks about possible teleportation. And who is in that room? Sardok, Eye of Oryx. Maybe that is the eye they are screaming about. And maybe not relevant, but the dead ghost containing the A113 grimoire is found in the shrine of oryx as well
-
Edited by A Rising Wind: 1/14/2016 8:22:52 PM10). I believe the awoken were created by being exposed to the darkness during the collapse. Perhaps quite literally, as in exposed to worm parasite that altered them. I've always wondered if the Awoken birth "ceremony" was simply the removal of the parasite. In fact, tin foil hat time, I find it interesting that the awoken grimoire card talks about an old unidentified derelict ship floating in the reef when humans went there the first time. Who else in grimoire floats around in a ship, following the traveler around because they know the hive will show up. Someone who helps those with the traveler with Intel on how to fight the hive? Taox. She showed up to many other species visited by the traveler. So what is this ship of origins unknown just floating there...waiting? Why is it under the awoken grimoire? Is it coincidence that the awoken in the reef where the ship was found were the ones who knew how to cripple the dreadnaught? I think Taox was waiting in the reef. I think Taox helped the awoken survive the exposure to the darkness. I think Taox armed the awoken with the intel to stop the dreadnaught so we could kill Oryx. I think it was all part of the plan
-
How did the vex covert entire worlds into machines in days?
-
The Dead Orbit Ghost Fragment is a reference to the Pixar movie [i] Monsters INC.[/i] They look through a keyhole in a door that the monsters use to enter earth rooms and gather screams. That's what they see. A-113 is the classroom number many Pixar employees had the California Institute of the Arts for character animation. They, along with graduates who didn't go to Pixar to work, include it in many movies as an Easter egg. This was just a nod to that.
-
When will akka return? He is dead but far from gone. We even see oryx sacrifice to akka.
-
For number one we have one account of overexposure to radiolorians. Kabr the titan, you know how he says he drank of them and they tasted like the sea, because radiolorians are a type of protozoa whose skeletons make up a majority of the seafloor so they're found in earth's oceans, anyways the overexposure drove him insane along with the thought that he knew he didn't go into the vault alone but that he couldn't remember who he went with. At least that's what I gathered from the grimiore and stuff.
-
Edited by RockNRollTrouble: 1/11/2016 5:04:36 PMI can explain question 8 Its like turning two radio's that are sitting beside eachother up full. Oryx kills savathun and becomes a cunning strategist. Killing her twice wouldnt mean he was twice as cunning, in the same way two radios wouldnt generate twice the volume. Theres also a paradox in doing so, if quria kills 100 hive, then goes back in time and kills the same 100 hive he is stealing the kills from himself
-
Hey Kagehoshi, I have seen your writings on the visions of Savathûn and her throne. I must ask, where do you thing Xivû Arath is? Will we see her on anything? Have you any visions of her and her whereabouts?
-
Other questions that I've been curious: [b]1) Given all of the Hive's knowledge of the arcane, why have we only faced three reborn Ogres? (Phogoth, Gulrot, The Infantine)(Note: The latter was not fully reborn, but was in the process of being reborn when we interrupted the ritual and killed it in The Summoner's Circle)[/b] [b]2) What is the purpose of the Vex programming Alphix Invasive?[/b] (I am unsure about this one, although they could be dedicated to specifically combat Guardians, like how Hezen Corrective is specifically programmed to combat the Fallen in Venus)
-
Damn. I'm really curious about the Eye found by Dead Orbit.
-
Can the ahamkara truly die?
-
Where do Eliksni say the Awoken are infertile?
-
Edited by ChiefKain: 1/10/2016 2:01:40 AMAn answer to question 3: Toland the shattered learned from the hive arcana and created his journal with all sorts of details of hive magic that he could wield. Eris morn learned from this as well eris even did some magic that makes the most learned warlocks scratch their heads. She somehow using hive magic pulled guardians out of a hive throne world(this happened in the mission last rites) the greatest praxic scholars can resurrect themselves. But they couldn't do that. But some way a (ex)Hunter did that. So I would say yea guardians or ex guardians could learn and wield hive/worm/vex/darkness magic and power. I don't have answers for any more of your questions but it was a great read. And my imagination is running wild thinking of answers for myself.