After reading through some comments I see that it's just a majority of people fan-boying/girling over their favourite character.
I would really appreciate it if someone would be kind enough to tell me ACTUAL details on who would be better.
[spoiler]I personally think that the Guardians would win because of exotics and supers[/spoiler]
English
-
Actually seeing some nice descriptive info. Thanks guys!
-
Edited by Spectre Ronin: 8/4/2015 7:27:33 AMGuardians are weaker, slower, and not as well trained. Their (personal) weaponry is technically similar in capability. Cheif's armor is significantly stronger and more advanced also chief weighs more than the canal do. Like seriously cabal are 800lbs. Chief in that armor is 990lbs. Also chief can lift a couple thousand pounds in said armor as well as run 60+ mph, but no more than 74, that speed will tear his Achilles tendon. When it comes to training, physical capabilities, equipment, and comparable feats it's master chief hands down. But we don't know exactly how an arc blade, golden gun, flat of havoc, nova bomb or any super would effect him. If they act in a similar manor in regards to shielding we have to match their abilities to his available equipment like overshields, jumpjets, bubble shield, Spartan laser, and armor lock. If we're comparing them in the context of all their abilities and equipment them Chief technically has to win because his equipment can match, counter, or out do that of a guardian, but If we're talking no firearms then chief has a significant advantage at the beginning of the fight while a super is not charged and then a moderate to significant disadvantage near the end of the fight depending on the super. But in the end chiefs reflexes, physical strength, training, speed, and mindset on the battlefield are unmatched by any guardian as we currently know them. I personally would like to think a bladedancer is faster and a titan would be just as strong but the fact of the matter is that we have no hard facts or measurable feats of skill, strength, or speed of guardians all we know is that they have not been able to stand against any great opponent alone. Their greatest achievements and battles are won as teams while chief's have been done alone against comparable insurmountable enemies of great world altering power. This debate can't truly be decided until we know more of what guardians are really capable of and have a better idea of their strength, skill, and speed
-
Edited by Bizomin: 8/4/2015 6:02:12 PMBut in the game he can die,to any halo enemy ,am I right ? So if we take movies or books,not in game facts then guardians would win,Titans are almost indestructible they command the battlefield,they're state as demons in the combat fighting with only one goal ,kill everything in their way. Warlocks are state as being able of altering the reality ,from knowing the deepest secrets of the universe ,their minds are the strongest arsenal in the universe (that's write in a grimoire or in an armor don't remember)Osiris find out how to manipulate time and space . I'm not stating you're wrong ,just debating bc is a little bit unfair putting a 14 year old franchise ,one of the biggest in the world ,agains a one year old ,that's the exact same thing as put a teenager against a children
-
Your absolutely right though. Destiny just hasn't been around long enough for its world to grow with details and examples that current franchises have. I eagerly await for destiny's growth so we can say with affirmation that a titan can fight a spartan 2, that a warlock could last a round with a jedi, and that a hunter could out stealth solid snake.
-
The difference from the worlds still stands because we don't see any indestructible titan we don't actually get to alter and bend reality as a warlock. Your comparing myths and legends from one universe to actual recorded facts in the other universe. You can't compare lore to a military dossier because lore, myths, and legend at their core are hyperbole of actual events. Guardians still die. Titans still get destroyed by any normal gun. Warlock powers are still very limited. Guardians do seem to be immortal but only if a ghost is near the traveler's light and ghosts can be killed which a trained military operative would notice. If you include lore and the myths surrounding guardians and not just facts you have to do the same for master chief. And the lore and myths surrounding him from 3 different alien races is that he is an immortal unstoppable demon of war not a simple individual but a single undying force of war that can (and has) slay armies alone. I'm not a halo fan boy I simply know the character. I'm a desticle and want guardians to be stronger faster and more powerful but I will not make arguments on their behalf based on assumptions and myths without including Chief's assumptions and myths because omitting information or including a type of information on one side only is a bias argument and not an actual comparison. Because if we include all the myths and assumptions based on them of guardians, chief still wins because of current assumptions about him being a crafted and perfected template of the forerunner Bornsteller and his abilities to be recognised as him by forerunner technologies such as the monitors like guilty spark. At that point it's no longer a guardian vs chief its a guardian vs one of the most powerful forerunners to have ever existed in the halo universe who has access and capability to control and manipulate all forerunner tech that recognizes Bornsteller(this includes the halo rings)
-
I know that man lol That's what I said ,we can only compared in game facts ,what the MC can do and what a guardian can do ,cause In the outside story we both know they're almost gods lol So that's why this debate will never end a guardian will never face MC enemy's and MC will never face destiny enemy's
-
Someone needs to get screw attack on this. Like a fireteam vs blue team
-
Agree or alpha against bravo lol
-
Master Chief killed 3 ODSTs with his bare arms and without any armor in 1 minute or so when he was 6 years old. Not every guardian is as skilled and well trained as an ODST. I think that a whole fireteam of Guardians don't have any chances against Master Chief.
-
Lol wasn't that on accident to? Like they were sparing weren't they? Haha
-
Edited by nevai: 8/4/2015 10:55:42 AMNo, he tried to flee from training camp as far as I remember and they were sent to stop him, but I don't remember how exactly that happened so I may be wrong about details.
-
Edited by Afawafa: 8/4/2015 7:15:26 AMIt's hard since there's almost no useful examples of guardian equipment or abilities. There's lore saying that Spartans can run at X mph, lift Y amount of weight and react within Z milliseconds, but the most you have for Guardian capabilities is "a snap of annihilating current" or "power of a collapsing star" which probably can't be taken too literally. There's no proof that Titans are stronger than Spartans and there's also no proof that they're weaker than Spartans.
-
Spartan IIs are super augmented soldiers, trained since the age of six, with enhanced brain capacity and reaction time. Their armor is made of multiple layers of the most advanced armors in the world. Their brains are wired to their suits so moving their arm moves the arm of the suit, which is why the Spartans can run and jump and all that stuff, while weighing multiple tons. On what you said about supers, Spartan IIs can either outrun, dodge, or counter attack every single super. Fist of Havoc - Spartan armor locks Ward of Dawn - Spartan pops with Spartan laser of just waits it out Nova Bomb - Spartan could actually outrun it Radiance - even a guardian can counter this easily Golden Gun - Spartan can dodge it (they have been known to dodge sniper bullets) Arc Blade - Spartan could turn the blade onto the hunter wielding it (highly trained in hand to hand combat and with increase reaction time, could dodge the blade faster than the blade could be swung)
-
First a warlock can 'blind' all the enemy when SR And a blade dancer can go invisible and kill a spartan with a back stab that in the game kills anything in kne hit kill A Titan would place a bubble when the Spartan come close enough ,and blind then or ward of dawn then A nova bomb tracks
-
Blinding a Spartan doesn't seem that effective because the effect doesn't last very long, and as soon as the warlock melees the Spartan, he knows exactly where he is and will beat his ass Spartans have been fighting invisible enemies for a long time. The elites' cloaking devices are much better than a hunter's. Spartan's wouldn't advance right next to an enemy. They only engage in hand to hand combat when the enemy comes to them, rendering the blinding bubble, useless Lol, nova bomb tracking sucks